{ "schema_version": "1.1.0", "release": "0.2.2", "assessment_state": "frozen", "scope_counts": { "pilot_journals": { "unit": "journal", "count": 25 }, "operational_pool": { "unit": "journal", "count": 85 }, "primary_articles": { "unit": "article", "count": 250 }, "c2_eligible_articles": { "unit": "article", "count": 86 }, "reference_assertions": { "unit": "pid_assertion", "count": 398 }, "adjudicated_reference_assertions": { "unit": "pid_assertion", "count": 396 }, "stage0_assessed_journals": { "unit": "journal", "count": 100 }, "candidate_frame": { "unit": "journal", "count": 137 }, "stage0_gate_pass_journals": { "unit": "journal", "count": 93 } }, "availability": { "full_sample_flow": "available", "stage0_results": "available", "stage0_rubric": "available", "indicator_definitions": "available", "dimension_normalized_scores": "available", "weight_dictionary": "available", "weighting_sensitivity": "stored_comparator_scores_and_summary" }, "sample_flow": [ { "stage": "candidates", "count": 137, "availability": "available" }, { "stage": "eligible", "count": 100, "availability": "available" }, { "stage": "stage0_gate_pass", "count": 93, "availability": "available" }, { "stage": "operational_stage1_pool", "count": 85, "availability": "available" }, { "stage": "pilot", "count": 25, "availability": "available" } ], "core_structure": { "dimension_ids": [ "D1", "D2", "D3", "D4" ], "indicator_ids": [ "I1.1", "I1.2", "I1.3", "I2.1", "I2.2", "I2.3", "I3.1", "I3.2", "I3.3", "I4.1", "I4.2", "I4.3" ], "indicator_scale": [ 0, 100 ], "dimension_measure": "weighted_contribution_to_m1", "m1_scale": [ 0, 100 ], "dimension_normalized_scale": [ 0, 100 ] }, "filter_categories": { "region": [ "northern_africa", "western_africa", "central_africa", "eastern_africa", "southern_africa" ], "recorded_language": [ "english", "arabic", "french", "afaan_oromo", "portuguese" ], "platform_category": [ "commercial_publisher", "repository_digital_commons", "other_institutional_platform", "asjp_national_platform", "imist_linked_platform", "university_institutional_ojs", "university_ojs_ajol", "ajol_linked_journal", "direct_institutional_web", "independent_institutional_site", "university_journal_portal", "repository_journal", "university_ojs_scielo" ], "selection_doi_status": [ "yes", "none", "mixed", "pending" ] }, "headlines": [ { "id": "c2_eligible", "numerator": 86, "denominator": 250, "denominator_scope": "primary_articles", "percent": 34.4 }, { "id": "c2_eligibility_not_verifiable", "numerator": 7, "denominator": 250, "denominator_scope": "primary_articles", "percent": 2.8 }, { "id": "c2_pid_identity_ineligible", "numerator": 157, "denominator": 250, "denominator_scope": "primary_articles", "percent": 62.8 }, { "id": "c2_retrieved", "numerator": 15, "denominator": 86, "denominator_scope": "c2_eligible_articles", "percent": 17.441860465116278 }, { "id": "c2_not_retrieved", "numerator": 71, "denominator": 86, "denominator_scope": "c2_eligible_articles", "percent": 82.55813953488372 }, { "id": "c2_technical_unresolved", "numerator": 0, "denominator": 86, "denominator_scope": "c2_eligible_articles", "percent": 0 }, { "id": "c2_query_coverage", "numerator": 86, "denominator": 86, "denominator_scope": "c2_eligible_articles", "percent": 100 }, { "id": "c1_openalex_positive", "numerator": 13, "denominator": 25, "denominator_scope": "pilot_journals", "percent": 52 }, { "id": "c3_doaj_positive", "numerator": 5, "denominator": 25, "denominator_scope": "pilot_journals", "percent": 20 }, { "id": "c3_ajol_positive", "numerator": 6, "denominator": 25, "denominator_scope": "pilot_journals", "percent": 24 }, { "id": "c4_confirmed", "numerator": 13, "denominator": 25, "denominator_scope": "pilot_journals", "percent": 52 }, { "id": "c4_not_detected", "numerator": 9, "denominator": 25, "denominator_scope": "pilot_journals", "percent": 36 }, { "id": "c4_unresolved", "numerator": 3, "denominator": 25, "denominator_scope": "pilot_journals", "percent": 12 }, { "id": "reference_concordance", "numerator": 389, "denominator": 396, "denominator_scope": "adjudicated_reference_assertions", "percent": 98.23232323232324 }, { "id": "reference_coverage", "numerator": 396, "denominator": 398, "denominator_scope": "reference_assertions", "percent": 99.49748743718592 }, { "id": "d3_zero", "numerator": 23, "denominator": 25, "denominator_scope": "pilot_journals", "percent": 92 } ], "core_summary": { "journal_count": 25, "indicator_states": 300, "numeric_states": 218, "structural_na_states": 82, "unresolved_states": 0, "numeric_zero_states": 138, "numeric_100_states": 65, "d3_zero_journals": 23, "m1_floor_journals": 13, "m1_stored_rounded_statistics": { "mean": 22.2364, "median": 6.6667, "sample_sd": 22.0012, "min": 6.6667, "max": 72.8537 } }, "journals": [ { "id": "C001", "filters": { "region": "northern_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "commercial_publisher", "selection_doi_status": "yes" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I3.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 9.96 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 20, "D2": 17, "D3": 35, "D4": 0.8537142857142858 }, "m1": 72.85371428571429, "d3_hard_zero": false, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "confirmed_positive", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "unresolved" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 10, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 10, "retrieved": 10, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 100, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 0, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 100, "D2": 68, "D3": 100, "D4": 4.268571428571429 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 72.66266666666667, "m1_eqdim": 68.06714285714285, "delta_ewwithin": -0.19104761904762313, "delta_eqdim": -4.786571428571435 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Journal of Advanced Research", "affiliated_institution": "Cairo University", "country": "Egypt", "issn": "2090-1232", "eissn": "2090-1224", "official_journal_url": "https://www.sciencedirect.com/journal/journal-of-advanced-research" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "applicable" } }, { "id": "C006", "filters": { "region": "northern_africa", "recorded_language": "arabic", "platform_category": "asjp_national_platform", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Afkar wa Affak", "affiliated_institution": "University of Algiers 2 – Abou El Kacem Saadallah", "country": "Algeria", "issn": "2170-1431", "eissn": "2170-144X", "official_journal_url": "https://afkar-wa-affak.univ-alger2.dz/" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C014", "filters": { "region": "northern_africa", "recorded_language": "french", "platform_category": "imist_linked_platform", "selection_doi_status": "mixed" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 20, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 20, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "confirmed_positive", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 10, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 10, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 10, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 0, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 0, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 100, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 20, "m1_eqdim": 25, "delta_ewwithin": 0, "delta_eqdim": 5 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "L'IMPACT: Revue d'Études Littéraires, Linguistiques et Audiovisuelles", "affiliated_institution": "Cadi Ayyad University", "country": "Morocco", "issn": null, "eissn": "2820-7637", "official_journal_url": "https://revues.imist.ma/index.php/limpact" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C021", "filters": { "region": "northern_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "mixed" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 50.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I3.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 69.44 }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 20, "D2": 25, "D3": 24.444000000000003, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 69.444, "d3_hard_zero": false, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 10, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 10, "retrieved": 5, "not_retrieved": 5, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 50, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 0, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 100, "D2": 100, "D3": 69.84, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 70.60133333333333, "m1_eqdim": 67.46000000000001, "delta_ewwithin": 1.1573333333333267, "delta_eqdim": -1.9839999999999947 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Scientific Journal of University of Benghazi", "affiliated_institution": "University of Benghazi", "country": "Libya", "issn": "2790-1629", "eissn": "2790-1637", "official_journal_url": "https://journals.uob.edu.ly/index.php/sjuob/index" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "applicable" } }, { "id": "C024", "filters": { "region": "northern_africa", "recorded_language": "arabic", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "yes" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 20, "D2": 25, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 45, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 10, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 10, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 10, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 0, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 0, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 100, "D2": 100, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 45, "m1_eqdim": 50, "delta_ewwithin": 0, "delta_eqdim": 5 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "حوليات كلية الآداب والعلوم الإنسانية", "affiliated_institution": "University of Nouakchott", "country": "Mauritania", "issn": "2523-1863", "eissn": null, "official_journal_url": "https://ejournals.univ-nkc.mr/index.php/AFLSH" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C028", "filters": { "region": "western_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "university_ojs_ajol", "selection_doi_status": "yes" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "confirmed_positive", "c4": "not_detected" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Ghana Journal of Geography", "affiliated_institution": "University of Ghana, Department of Geography and Resource Development", "country": "Ghana", "issn": "0855-9414", "eissn": "2821-8892", "official_journal_url": "https://journals.ug.edu.gh/index.php/gjg" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C033", "filters": { "region": "western_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "direct_institutional_web", "selection_doi_status": "yes" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 20, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 20, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "confirmed_positive", "c3_ajol": "confirmed_positive", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 10, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 10, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 10, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 0, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 0, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 100, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 20, "m1_eqdim": 25, "delta_ewwithin": 0, "delta_eqdim": 5 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Journal of Economics and Allied Research", "affiliated_institution": "University of Nigeria, Nsukka, Department of Economics / CCEAR", "country": "Nigeria", "issn": "2536-7447", "eissn": "3043-6591", "official_journal_url": "https://jearecons.com/" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C038", "filters": { "region": "western_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "ajol_linked_journal", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "confirmed_positive", "c4": "not_detected" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "African Journal of Ancient Sciences SUNU XALAAT", "affiliated_institution": "Cheikh Anta Diop University, Faculty of Arts and Humanities", "country": "Senegal", "issn": "2772-2104", "eissn": null, "official_journal_url": "https://afrosciences-antiquity.com/" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C041", "filters": { "region": "western_africa", "recorded_language": "french", "platform_category": "independent_institutional_site", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "not_detected" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Perspectives Plurielles", "affiliated_institution": "Université Alassane Ouattara", "country": "Côte d’Ivoire", "issn": "3105-8485", "eissn": "3105-8493", "official_journal_url": "https://perspectivesplurielles.net/" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C046", "filters": { "region": "western_africa", "recorded_language": "french", "platform_category": "independent_institutional_site", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "not_detected" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Climat & Développement", "affiliated_institution": "Université d'Abomey-Calavi, LACEEDE", "country": "Benin", "issn": "1840-5452", "eissn": null, "official_journal_url": "https://revue-climatetdeveloppement.org/" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C053", "filters": { "region": "central_africa", "recorded_language": "french", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "yes" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 80.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 13, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 13, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 65, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 12, "m1_eqdim": 16.25, "delta_ewwithin": -1, "delta_eqdim": 3.25 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Revue de l’Université du Burundi – Série Sciences Humaines et Sociales", "affiliated_institution": "University of Burundi", "country": "Burundi", "issn": null, "eissn": null, "official_journal_url": "https://revue.ub.edu.bi/index/fr" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C057", "filters": { "region": "central_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "pending" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "African Journal of Law and Politics", "affiliated_institution": "University of Bamenda, Faculty of Law and Political Science", "country": "Cameroon", "issn": "3006-2799", "eissn": "3006-2802", "official_journal_url": "https://journals.flps-uba.cm/ajlp" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C063", "filters": { "region": "central_africa", "recorded_language": "french", "platform_category": "direct_institutional_web", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Annales de l’Université de Bangui — Série A", "affiliated_institution": "University of Bangui", "country": "Central African Republic", "issn": "2663-3701", "eissn": null, "official_journal_url": "https://www.surandara-ub.org/" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C067", "filters": { "region": "central_africa", "recorded_language": "french", "platform_category": "university_journal_portal", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "not_detected" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Annales de la Faculté des Lettres, Arts et Sciences Humaines", "affiliated_institution": "University of Moundou", "country": "Chad", "issn": "2304-1056", "eissn": "2707-6830", "official_journal_url": "https://www.aflash-revue-mdou.org/" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C079", "filters": { "region": "central_africa", "recorded_language": "french", "platform_category": "independent_institutional_site", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "not_detected" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Revue Gabonaise de Littératures & Sciences Humaines", "affiliated_institution": "Omar Bongo University, Department of Modern Letters / CERLIM", "country": "Gabon", "issn": null, "eissn": "2520-9809", "official_journal_url": "https://www.regalish.net/" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C084", "filters": { "region": "eastern_africa", "recorded_language": "afaan_oromo", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "yes" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 20, "D2": 25, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 45, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "confirmed_positive", "c4": "unresolved" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 10, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 10, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 10, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 0, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 0, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 100, "D2": 100, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 45, "m1_eqdim": 50, "delta_ewwithin": 0, "delta_eqdim": 5 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Gadaa Journal", "affiliated_institution": "Jimma University, Institute of Oromo Studies", "country": "Ethiopia", "issn": "2616-3977", "eissn": "2616-3985", "official_journal_url": "https://journals.ju.edu.et/index.php/gadaa" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C088", "filters": { "region": "eastern_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 80.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 64.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 80.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 19, "D2": 14.08, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 33.08, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 1, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 7, "successfully_queried": 1, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 1, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 0, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 2, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 95, "D2": 56.32, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 30.666666666666664, "m1_eqdim": 37.83, "delta_ewwithin": -2.413333333333334, "delta_eqdim": 4.75 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "African Development Finance Journal", "affiliated_institution": "University of Nairobi, Department of Finance and Accounting", "country": "Kenya", "issn": null, "eissn": "2522-3186", "official_journal_url": "https://www.uonjournals.uonbi.ac.ke/index.php/adfj" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C094", "filters": { "region": "eastern_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "ajol_linked_journal", "selection_doi_status": "yes" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 20, "D2": 25, "D3": 0, "D4": 8 }, "m1": 53, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "confirmed_positive", "c3_ajol": "confirmed_positive", "c4": "not_detected" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 10, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 10, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 10, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 0, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 0, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 100, "D2": 100, "D3": 0, "D4": 40 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 51.66666666666667, "m1_eqdim": 60, "delta_ewwithin": -1.3333333333333286, "delta_eqdim": 7 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Rwanda Journal of Medicine and Health Sciences", "affiliated_institution": "University of Rwanda, College of Medicine and Health Sciences", "country": "Rwanda", "issn": "2616-9819", "eissn": "2616-9827", "official_journal_url": "https://www.rjmhs.ur.ac.rw/" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C097", "filters": { "region": "eastern_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "direct_institutional_web", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "not_detected" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Somali Studies Journal", "affiliated_institution": "Mogadishu University, Institute for Somali Studies", "country": "Somalia", "issn": "2414-6501", "eissn": "2517-9810", "official_journal_url": "https://www.isos.so/index.php/journal" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C099", "filters": { "region": "eastern_africa", "recorded_language": "arabic", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "yes" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 50.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 50.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 50.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 50.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 17.5, "D2": 12.5, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 30, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "not_detected" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 5, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 5, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 5, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 0, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 5, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 87.5, "D2": 50, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 29.166666666666664, "m1_eqdim": 34.375, "delta_ewwithin": -0.8333333333333357, "delta_eqdim": 4.375 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Omdurman Islamic University Journal", "affiliated_institution": "Omdurman Islamic University", "country": "Sudan", "issn": "1858-6198", "eissn": null, "official_journal_url": "https://journal.oiu.edu.sd/index.php/oiuj" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C112", "filters": { "region": "southern_africa", "recorded_language": "portuguese", "platform_category": "independent_institutional_site", "selection_doi_status": "pending" }, "multilingual": true, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Revista Científica da Universidade José Eduardo dos Santos", "affiliated_institution": "Universidade José Eduardo dos Santos", "country": "Angola", "issn": null, "eissn": "3006-9688", "official_journal_url": "https://www.reciujes.com/index.php/reciujes" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C116", "filters": { "region": "southern_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "unresolved" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "UNESWA Journal of Education", "affiliated_institution": "University of Eswatini", "country": "Eswatini", "issn": null, "eissn": "2616-3012", "official_journal_url": "https://ojs.uneswa.ac.sz/index.php/ujoe" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C125", "filters": { "region": "southern_africa", "recorded_language": "portuguese", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "none" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 6.666666666666668, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 6.666666666666668, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "verified_negative", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 33.333333333333336, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 8.333333333333334, "delta_ewwithin": 3.333333333333332, "delta_eqdim": 1.666666666666666 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "MOÇAMBIQUE GEODIVERSO", "affiliated_institution": "Universidade Pedagógica de Maputo, Faculdade de Ciências da Terra e Ambiente", "country": "Mozambique", "issn": null, "eissn": null, "official_journal_url": "https://revistas.up.ac.mz/mozgeo" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C127", "filters": { "region": "southern_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "university_institutional_ojs", "selection_doi_status": "mixed" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 50.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 10, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "m1": 10, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "verified_negative", "c3_ajol": "verified_negative", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 0, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 0, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 0, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": null, "query_coverage_percent": null, "pid_identity_ineligible": 10, "rate_state": "no_confirmed_eligible_articles" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 50, "D2": 0, "D3": 0, "D4": 0 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 10, "m1_eqdim": 12.5, "delta_ewwithin": 0, "delta_eqdim": 2.5 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Journal for Studies in Humanities and Social Sciences", "affiliated_institution": "University of Namibia, Faculty of Humanities and Social Sciences", "country": "Namibia", "issn": "2026-7215", "eissn": "2026-8637", "official_journal_url": "https://journals.unam.edu.na/index.php/JSHSS" }, "applicability": { "c2": "not_assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } }, { "id": "C129", "filters": { "region": "southern_africa", "recorded_language": "english", "platform_category": "university_ojs_scielo", "selection_doi_status": "yes" }, "multilingual": false, "indicators": { "I1.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I1.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I2.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 100.0 }, "I3.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 0.0 }, "I3.2": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I3.3": { "state": "structural_na", "value": null }, "I4.1": { "state": "observed", "value": 40.0 }, "I4.2": { "state": "observed", "value": 60.0 }, "I4.3": { "state": "observed", "value": 94.44 } }, "dimension_contributions": { "D1": 20, "D2": 25, "D3": 0, "D4": 12.866399999999999 }, "m1": 57.8664, "d3_hard_zero": true, "contextual_states": { "c1_openalex": "confirmed_positive", "c3_doaj": "confirmed_positive", "c3_ajol": "confirmed_positive", "c4": "confirmed" }, "c2": { "primary_articles": 10, "confirmed_eligible": 10, "eligibility_not_verifiable": 0, "successfully_queried": 10, "retrieved": 0, "not_retrieved": 10, "technical_unresolved": 0, "retrievability_percent": 0, "query_coverage_percent": 100, "pid_identity_ineligible": 0, "rate_state": "defined" }, "dimension_normalized_scores": { "D1": 100, "D2": 100, "D3": 0, "D4": 64.332 }, "weighting_comparators": { "m1_ewwithin": 57.962666666666664, "m1_eqdim": 66.083, "delta_ewwithin": 0.09626666666666495, "delta_eqdim": 8.2166 }, "identity": { "journal_name": "Acta Structilia", "affiliated_institution": "University of the Free State", "country": "South Africa", "issn": "1023-0564", "eissn": "2415-0487", "official_journal_url": "https://journals.ufs.ac.za/index.php/as" }, "applicability": { "c2": "assessable", "reference_pid": "not_applicable" } } ], "reference_pid": { "applicable_journal_ids": [ "C001", "C021" ], "deep_audit_articles": 10, "deposited_reference_rows": 471, "results": [ { "scope": "C001", "assertions": 276, "concordant": 274, "discordant": 1, "invalid_unregistered": 1, "unresolved": 0, "adjudicated": 276, "concordance_percent": 99.27536231884058, "coverage_percent": 100 }, { "scope": "C021", "assertions": 122, "concordant": 115, "discordant": 2, "invalid_unregistered": 3, "unresolved": 2, "adjudicated": 120, "concordance_percent": 95.83333333333334, "coverage_percent": 98.36065573770492 }, { "scope": "combined", "assertions": 398, "concordant": 389, "discordant": 3, "invalid_unregistered": 4, "unresolved": 2, "adjudicated": 396, "concordance_percent": 98.23232323232324, "coverage_percent": 99.49748743718592 } ] }, "weighting_sensitivity": [ { "comparison": "m1_vs_equal_within_dimension_weights", "mean_absolute_difference": 2.0143, "spearman_rho": 0.979421 }, { "comparison": "m1_vs_equal_dimension_budgets", "mean_absolute_difference": 3.1412, "spearman_rho": 1.0 } ], "selection_comparisons": [ { "filter": "region", "category": "northern_africa", "pool_n": 20, "pool_proportion": 0.23529411764705882, "pilot_n": 5, "pilot_proportion": 0.2, "absolute_pp_difference": 3.529411764705881 }, { "filter": "region", "category": "western_africa", "pool_n": 17, "pool_proportion": 0.2, "pilot_n": 5, "pilot_proportion": 0.2, "absolute_pp_difference": 0 }, { "filter": "region", "category": "central_africa", "pool_n": 10, "pool_proportion": 0.11764705882352941, "pilot_n": 5, "pilot_proportion": 0.2, "absolute_pp_difference": 8.23529411764706 }, { "filter": "region", "category": "eastern_africa", "pool_n": 23, "pool_proportion": 0.27058823529411763, "pilot_n": 5, "pilot_proportion": 0.2, "absolute_pp_difference": 7.058823529411762 }, { "filter": "region", "category": "southern_africa", "pool_n": 15, "pool_proportion": 0.17647058823529413, "pilot_n": 5, "pilot_proportion": 0.2, "absolute_pp_difference": 2.3529411764705883 }, { "filter": "recorded_language", "category": "english", "pool_n": 55, "pool_proportion": 0.6470588235294118, "pilot_n": 12, "pilot_proportion": 0.48, "absolute_pp_difference": 16.70588235294118 }, { "filter": "recorded_language", "category": "arabic", "pool_n": 11, "pool_proportion": 0.12941176470588237, "pilot_n": 3, "pilot_proportion": 0.12, "absolute_pp_difference": 0.941176470588237 }, { "filter": "recorded_language", "category": "french", "pool_n": 16, "pool_proportion": 0.18823529411764706, "pilot_n": 7, "pilot_proportion": 0.28, "absolute_pp_difference": 9.176470588235297 }, { "filter": "recorded_language", "category": "afaan_oromo", "pool_n": 1, "pool_proportion": 0.011764705882352941, "pilot_n": 1, "pilot_proportion": 0.04, "absolute_pp_difference": 2.823529411764706 }, { "filter": "recorded_language", "category": "portuguese", "pool_n": 2, "pool_proportion": 0.023529411764705882, "pilot_n": 2, "pilot_proportion": 0.08, "absolute_pp_difference": 5.647058823529412 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "commercial_publisher", "pool_n": 3, "pool_proportion": 0.03529411764705882, "pilot_n": 1, "pilot_proportion": 0.04, "absolute_pp_difference": 0.47058823529411775 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "repository_digital_commons", "pool_n": 2, "pool_proportion": 0.023529411764705882, "pilot_n": 0, "pilot_proportion": 0, "absolute_pp_difference": 2.3529411764705883 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "other_institutional_platform", "pool_n": 3, "pool_proportion": 0.03529411764705882, "pilot_n": 0, "pilot_proportion": 0, "absolute_pp_difference": 3.5294117647058822 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "asjp_national_platform", "pool_n": 5, "pool_proportion": 0.058823529411764705, "pilot_n": 1, "pilot_proportion": 0.04, "absolute_pp_difference": 1.8823529411764703 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "imist_linked_platform", "pool_n": 5, "pool_proportion": 0.058823529411764705, "pilot_n": 1, "pilot_proportion": 0.04, "absolute_pp_difference": 1.8823529411764703 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "university_institutional_ojs", "pool_n": 38, "pool_proportion": 0.4470588235294118, "pilot_n": 10, "pilot_proportion": 0.4, "absolute_pp_difference": 4.705882352941177 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "university_ojs_ajol", "pool_n": 5, "pool_proportion": 0.058823529411764705, "pilot_n": 1, "pilot_proportion": 0.04, "absolute_pp_difference": 1.8823529411764703 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "ajol_linked_journal", "pool_n": 9, "pool_proportion": 0.10588235294117647, "pilot_n": 2, "pilot_proportion": 0.08, "absolute_pp_difference": 2.5882352941176467 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "direct_institutional_web", "pool_n": 4, "pool_proportion": 0.047058823529411764, "pilot_n": 3, "pilot_proportion": 0.12, "absolute_pp_difference": 7.294117647058823 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "independent_institutional_site", "pool_n": 5, "pool_proportion": 0.058823529411764705, "pilot_n": 4, "pilot_proportion": 0.16, "absolute_pp_difference": 10.117647058823529 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "university_journal_portal", "pool_n": 3, "pool_proportion": 0.03529411764705882, "pilot_n": 1, "pilot_proportion": 0.04, "absolute_pp_difference": 0.47058823529411775 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "repository_journal", "pool_n": 2, "pool_proportion": 0.023529411764705882, "pilot_n": 0, "pilot_proportion": 0, "absolute_pp_difference": 2.3529411764705883 }, { "filter": "platform_category", "category": "university_ojs_scielo", "pool_n": 1, "pool_proportion": 0.011764705882352941, "pilot_n": 1, "pilot_proportion": 0.04, "absolute_pp_difference": 2.823529411764706 }, { "filter": "selection_doi_status", "category": "yes", "pool_n": 40, "pool_proportion": 0.47058823529411764, "pilot_n": 9, "pilot_proportion": 0.36, "absolute_pp_difference": 11.058823529411764 }, { "filter": "selection_doi_status", "category": "none", "pool_n": 35, "pool_proportion": 0.4117647058823529, "pilot_n": 11, "pilot_proportion": 0.44, "absolute_pp_difference": 2.8235294117647083 }, { "filter": "selection_doi_status", "category": "mixed", "pool_n": 5, "pool_proportion": 0.058823529411764705, "pilot_n": 3, "pilot_proportion": 0.12, "absolute_pp_difference": 6.117647058823529 }, { "filter": "selection_doi_status", "category": "pending", "pool_n": 5, "pool_proportion": 0.058823529411764705, "pilot_n": 2, "pilot_proportion": 0.08, "absolute_pp_difference": 2.11764705882353 } ], "interpretation_keys": [ "pilot_is_purposive", "no_population_prevalence", "no_journal_quality_ranking", "context_does_not_replace_core", "c2_empty_response_is_not_verified_absence", "c2_zero_eligible_is_undefined", "reference_pid_conditional_scope", "selection_descriptors_are_not_final_outcomes", "unresolved_is_final_assessment_state" ], "stage0": { "release": "0.2.1", "assessed_journals": 100, "criterion_ids": [ "G1", "G2", "G3", "G4", "G5" ], "criterion_scale": [ 0, 2 ], "total_scale": [ 0, 10 ], "rule": { "minimum_total": 7, "minimum_g3": 1, "minimum_g4": 1, "unverifiable_prevents_final_gate": true, "included_in_core": false, "status": "frozen_for_pilot_provisional_beyond_pilot" }, "outcome_counts": { "core_assessment_accessible": 87, "conditional_core_assessment": 6, "foundational_capacity_building": 6, "unresolved": 1 }, "gate_pass_counts": { "yes": 93, "no": 6, "unresolved": 1 }, "criterion_distributions": [ { "criterion": "G1", "score_0": 0, "score_1": 1, "score_2": 99, "unverifiable": 0, "denominator": 100 }, { "criterion": "G2", "score_0": 0, "score_1": 7, "score_2": 93, "unverifiable": 0, "denominator": 100 }, { "criterion": "G3", "score_0": 3, "score_1": 6, "score_2": 90, "unverifiable": 1, "denominator": 100 }, { "criterion": "G4", "score_0": 0, "score_1": 11, "score_2": 88, "unverifiable": 1, "denominator": 100 }, { "criterion": "G5", "score_0": 0, "score_1": 9, "score_2": 91, "unverifiable": 0, "denominator": 100 } ], "assessments": [ { "id": "C001", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C002", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C003", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C004", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C005", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C006", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C007", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C008", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C009", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C010", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C011", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C012", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C013", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C014", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C015", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C016", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 5 }, "gate_outcome": "foundational_capacity_building", "gate_pass": "no" }, { "id": "C017", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 5 }, "gate_outcome": "foundational_capacity_building", "gate_pass": "no" }, { "id": "C019", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 0 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 5 }, "gate_outcome": "foundational_capacity_building", "gate_pass": "no" }, { "id": "C020", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C021", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C022", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C023", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C024", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C026", "region": "northern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 6 }, "gate_outcome": "foundational_capacity_building", "gate_pass": "no" }, { "id": "C027", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C028", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C029", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C030", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C031", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C032", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C033", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C034", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C037", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C038", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C039", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C040", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 7 }, "gate_outcome": "conditional_core_assessment", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C041", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 9 }, "gate_outcome": "conditional_core_assessment", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C042", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C043", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C046", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C049", "region": "western_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C053", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C056", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C057", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C058", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G3": { "state": "unverifiable", "value": null }, "G4": { "state": "unverifiable", "value": null }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "unverifiable", "value": null }, "gate_outcome": "unresolved", "gate_pass": "unresolved" }, { "id": "C063", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 9 }, "gate_outcome": "conditional_core_assessment", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C064", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 7 }, "gate_outcome": "conditional_core_assessment", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C067", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C068", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 6 }, "gate_outcome": "foundational_capacity_building", "gate_pass": "no" }, { "id": "C069", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 6 }, "gate_outcome": "foundational_capacity_building", "gate_pass": "no" }, { "id": "C071", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C072", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C075", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C078", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C079", "region": "central_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 9 }, "gate_outcome": "conditional_core_assessment", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C083", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C084", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C085", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C086", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C087", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C088", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C089", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C090", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C094", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C096", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C097", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C098", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 1 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 9 }, "gate_outcome": "conditional_core_assessment", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C099", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C100", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C101", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C102", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C103", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C104", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C105", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C106", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C107", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C108", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C109", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C110", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C111", "region": "eastern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C112", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C113", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C114", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C115", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C116", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C120", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C121", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C125", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C126", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C127", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C128", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C129", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C130", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C131", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C132", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C133", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C134", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C135", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C136", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" }, { "id": "C137", "region": "southern_africa", "criteria": { "G1": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G2": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G3": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G4": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 }, "G5": { "state": "observed", "value": 2 } }, "gate_total": { "state": "observed", "value": 10 }, "gate_outcome": "core_assessment_accessible", "gate_pass": "yes" } ], "interpretation_keys": [ "stage0_assessability_not_quality", "stage0_unverifiable_not_zero", "stage0_g4_location_agnostic", "stage0_g5_reproducible_evidence_chain" ] }, "gate_pass_exclusions": { "count": 8, "reason": "not_sampleable_under_frozen_article_protocol", "note_key": "gate_pass_does_not_establish_sampleability" }, "methodology": { "version": "0.2.2", "dimensions": [ { "id": "D1", "weight": 20, "name_key": "core.dimensions.D1.name" }, { "id": "D2", "weight": 25, "name_key": "core.dimensions.D2.name" }, { "id": "D3", "weight": 35, "name_key": "core.dimensions.D3.name" }, { "id": "D4", "weight": 20, "name_key": "core.dimensions.D4.name" } ], "indicators": [ { "id": "I1.1", "dimension_id": "D1", "internal_weight": 5, "name_key": "core.indicators.I1_1.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I1_1.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I1_1.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I1_1.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I1_1.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I1.2", "dimension_id": "D1", "internal_weight": 10, "name_key": "core.indicators.I1_2.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I1_2.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I1_2.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I1_2.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I1_2.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I1.3", "dimension_id": "D1", "internal_weight": 5, "name_key": "core.indicators.I1_3.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I1_3.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I1_3.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I1_3.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I1_3.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I2.1", "dimension_id": "D2", "internal_weight": 12, "name_key": "core.indicators.I2_1.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I2_1.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I2_1.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I2_1.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I2_1.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I2.2", "dimension_id": "D2", "internal_weight": 8, "name_key": "core.indicators.I2_2.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I2_2.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I2_2.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I2_2.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I2_2.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I2.3", "dimension_id": "D2", "internal_weight": 5, "name_key": "core.indicators.I2_3.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I2_3.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I2_3.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I2_3.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I2_3.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I3.1", "dimension_id": "D3", "internal_weight": 15, "name_key": "core.indicators.I3_1.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I3_1.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I3_1.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I3_1.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I3_1.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I3.2", "dimension_id": "D3", "internal_weight": 10, "name_key": "core.indicators.I3_2.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I3_2.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I3_2.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I3_2.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I3_2.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I3.3", "dimension_id": "D3", "internal_weight": 10, "name_key": "core.indicators.I3_3.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I3_3.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I3_3.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I3_3.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I3_3.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I4.1", "dimension_id": "D4", "internal_weight": 6, "name_key": "core.indicators.I4_1.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I4_1.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I4_1.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I4_1.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I4_1.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I4.2", "dimension_id": "D4", "internal_weight": 8, "name_key": "core.indicators.I4_2.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I4_2.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I4_2.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I4_2.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I4_2.unverifiable" }, { "id": "I4.3", "dimension_id": "D4", "internal_weight": 6, "name_key": "core.indicators.I4_3.name", "operational_definition_key": "core.indicators.I4_3.operationalDefinition", "scoring_rule_key": "core.indicators.I4_3.scoringRule", "structural_na_rule_key": "core.indicators.I4_3.structuralNA", "unverifiable_rule_key": "core.indicators.I4_3.unverifiable" } ], "renormalisation": "within_dimension_applicable_indicators_only", "cross_dimension_weight_transfer": false, "stage0_included_in_core": false, "d3_audit_max_primary_articles": 5, "rule_keys": [ "core.states.zero", "core.states.structuralNA", "core.states.unverifiable", "core.evidenceSource", "core.noImputation", "core.sameFrozenPrimarySample", "core.d3AuditSubset", "core.i33LinkabilityRoutes", "core.renormalisation" ] }, "dimension_descriptives": [ { "dimension": "D1", "scale": "weighted_contribution", "n": 25, "maximum_possible": 20, "mean": 12.246666666666668, "median": 6.666666666666668, "sample_sd": 6.339383075487532, "min": 6.666666666666668, "q1": 6.66666666666667, "q3": 20, "iqr": 13.33333333333333, "max": 20, "zero_n": 0, "zero_proportion": 0, "at_maximum_n": 8, "at_maximum_proportion": 0.32 }, { "dimension": "D1", "scale": "normalized_0_100", "n": 25, "maximum_possible": 100, "mean": 61.23333333333334, "median": 33.333333333333336, "sample_sd": 31.69691537743766, "min": 33.333333333333336, "q1": 33.33333333333334, "q3": 100, "iqr": 66.66666666666666, "max": 100, "zero_n": 0, "zero_proportion": 0, "at_maximum_n": 8, "at_maximum_proportion": 0.32 }, { "dimension": "D2", "scale": "weighted_contribution", "n": 25, "maximum_possible": 25, "mean": 6.743199999999999, "median": 0, "sample_sd": 10.47164374234851, "min": 0, "q1": 0, "q3": 14.08, "iqr": 14.08, "max": 25, "zero_n": 17, "zero_proportion": 0.68, "at_maximum_n": 5, "at_maximum_proportion": 0.2 }, { "dimension": "D2", "scale": "normalized_0_100", "n": 25, "maximum_possible": 100, "mean": 26.972799999999996, "median": 0, "sample_sd": 41.88657496939404, "min": 0, "q1": 0, "q3": 56.32, "iqr": 56.32, "max": 100, "zero_n": 17, "zero_proportion": 0.68, "at_maximum_n": 5, "at_maximum_proportion": 0.2 }, { "dimension": "D3", "scale": "weighted_contribution", "n": 25, "maximum_possible": 35, "mean": 2.3777600000000003, "median": 0, "sample_sd": 8.369502102275861, "min": 0, "q1": 0, "q3": 0, "iqr": 0, "max": 35, "zero_n": 23, "zero_proportion": 0.92, "at_maximum_n": 1, "at_maximum_proportion": 0.04 }, { "dimension": "D3", "scale": "normalized_0_100", "n": 25, "maximum_possible": 100, "mean": 6.7936000000000005, "median": 0, "sample_sd": 23.912863149359577, "min": 0, "q1": 0, "q3": 0, "iqr": 0, "max": 100, "zero_n": 23, "zero_proportion": 0.92, "at_maximum_n": 1, "at_maximum_proportion": 0.04 }, { "dimension": "D4", "scale": "weighted_contribution", "n": 25, "maximum_possible": 20, "mean": 0.8688045714285714, "median": 0, "sample_sd": 2.9679014924848626, "min": 0, "q1": 0, "q3": 0, "iqr": 0, "max": 12.866399999999999, "zero_n": 22, "zero_proportion": 0.88, "at_maximum_n": 0, "at_maximum_proportion": 0 }, { "dimension": "D4", "scale": "normalized_0_100", "n": 25, "maximum_possible": 100, "mean": 4.344022857142857, "median": 0, "sample_sd": 14.839507462424313, "min": 0, "q1": 0, "q3": 0, "iqr": 0, "max": 64.332, "zero_n": 22, "zero_proportion": 0.88, "at_maximum_n": 0, "at_maximum_proportion": 0 } ] }